+41 (0) 21 544 7218 Contact Us

The Commentators Curse

The Commentators Curse

By In 15th World Bridge Series, Articles On 25th September 2018

Commentating on a bridge match is a dangerous occupation; it is all to easy to be blinded by the sight of all four hands, forgetting that the players can only see 13 cards during the bidding. It is also dangerous to make comments about the bidding without a sight of a convention card! Witness this deal from the third session of the Rosenblum round of 64:

Played by South, 6Picche is a good contract. Assuming spades are not 4-0,declarer could ruff a diamond lead in dummy and play a low spade, keeping control. Even with the 4-0 break West still has to lead a minor suit to defeat the slam – here West went for the Cuori5 and declarer won and ran the PiccheQ for an effortless 12 tricks.
One commentator described it as an unlucky board for NS, with Par being for them to play 6Fiori from the South hand with a lead out of turn (a spade lead from West followed by a heart switch beats 5Fiori).

North had the option of responding 4Quadri at his first turn, which would have promised a void. Another unlucky commentator wrote it would be perverse not to show the clubs, not appreciating that the initial response was artificial.
Assuming the bids after North had shown his spade support were control showing, there is a case for West to double 4Cuori.
East led the Fiori4 and declarer won in dummy, ruffed a diamond and drew trumps, pitching diamonds from dummy. Our eager commentator opined that East needed to lead a heart to defeat 6Fiori, pointing out that it isn’t easy to do that looking at the QuadriAK. That’s spot on, but he then pronounced that even without a heart lead West would be able to defeat the contract by ducking in spades. If at this point declarer lays down the PiccheA and then plays a spade to the queen that’s right, although West can also win and exit with a red card. However, declarer had no intention of going down – he played the Picche8 and put up dummy’s queen, claiming his contract. If West wins declarer can pick up his spades and still has a heart entry to dummy to enjoy the fifth spade and ducking does not help at all.

That’s not quite the end of the story.
You recall the comment (no doubt tongue in cheek) about South playing in 6Fiori?

This was the auction from the Closed Room in Fleisher v China Open 2:

West led the Quadri6 (not out of turn) and declarer more or less followed the line already described.
In the other room the auction started 1Picche-2NT*-3Fiori, but NS played in 6Quadri and West led his club, which meant declarer had no chance.

The two declarers featured in this article were the only ones to play in and make 6Fiori. One lucky South made 6Picche when West lead a heart.

About the Author